‘Oh, are you doing magic? Let’s see it, then.’

by sj

While I’ve read and re-read Harry Potter more times than I can count since my little brother (way little, he was then 10) introduced me to the first two books during a long road trip down to San Diego in the middle of my 8th month of pregnancy with my oldest (holy crap, could this sentence get longer?  Let’s see!), I haven’t picked them up in a few years.  I didn’t re-read them last year cos I was supposed to be reading all the NEW TO ME things, and the year before…I don’t even know what I was doing the year before that.  It was 2010 when I last picked up Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone to make that first trip to everything magical along with Harry.

I was reminded while reading this time why this was never my favourite of the series.  If I hadn’t been stuck in a car with my dad, both of my little brothers and my husband on that REALLY LONG DRIVE, I probably wouldn’t have read this in an hour and immediately moved onto Chamber of Secrets.  So, I suppose I should be grateful that I was trapped in that car, trying to avoid the need to pee because I can fully realize that a good portion of my love for this series comes from later volumes, and the friendships I made while waiting for Jo to just finish writing the damn thing.

Since I haven’t got much to say in the way of a review, as I’m pretty sure it’s all been said elsewhere before, I’ll just nitpick a few things:

It struck me this time as I was reading that Harry was 15 months old when Dumbledore left him wrapped up in a blanket on the Dursley’s front porch.  A FIFTEEN MONTH OLD!  LEFT ALONE ON A PORCH FOR THE WHOLE NIGHT!  I’d never really bothered to do the math before, but there’s no way I’d leave my 15 month old asleep on just the floor, cos I know they’d eventually wake up and get into everydamnthing.  This is kind of ridiculous (and I know, talking about ridiculous things in these books is rather defeatist, but still).  She couldn’t have thrown in a mention of a whispered spell or something so that we knew the kid wasn’t just being dumped off?

Harry realizes in Chapter 3 (“The Letters from No One”) that the next day (Tuesday) is his birthday.  If Harry was born July 31st 1980 (which we now know he was), his 11th birthday would have been on Wednesday.  This is the first of many examples where Jo shows that she’s a bear of very little brain and long words numbers bother her.  I’m currently reading the newly released Pottermore eEditions, so I’m not really sure why this hasn’t been fixed yet?  She has a problem with dates and numbers throughout the series, though, so this wasn’t really a surprise.  It more bothers me that no one has bothered to fix this (minor) detail in the last 15 years.

Lengthy Sidenote:

I’m terrible at video games.  I have the worst hand/eye coordination of anyone I’ve ever met.  I’m not even kidding.  Don’t throw things to me because I will not catch them.

The first video game that tied in with the movie (on the original Playstation) was perfect for me, though.  It was mostly running around the grounds of Hogwarts, collecting Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans and Wizard Cards – with occasional digressions to solve puzzles.  I didn’t have to be able to do anything fancy, and it was exactly the kind of game I like…by which I mean, one I can be good at without having to do much of anything.

levioSARBecause I played the shit out of that game (100%, even if they never let me into the damn broom closet in the entryway), every time I read these books, I hear the names of the textbook authors in my head in this voice like the one used in the game when you discovered something.  A bit of surprise and awe.   [gasp] Hengist of Woodcroft!

ALSO, this game had major save issues.  You couldn’t save when you wanted, you could only save after you passed, like, what would be the Boss portions in a normal video game.  I didn’t usually have a problem with this, but at the end when you’re trying to make it through all of the challenges to the Philosopher’s Stone, you had to get through ALL OF THE CHALLENGES before there was a save point.  I was good up until the troll.  Yes, like in the book, the troll is knocked out, but in the game he’s starting to wake up as you’re running past him.  So you have to use wingardium leviosa on all of these objects in his path that he might trip over, while still managing to avoid getting stomped.  I was the worst at this part of the game.  I tried for, like, 2 days to get past that stupid troll before I finally did, and then I died again at the next challenge.  Because I’m sometimes superstitious, I decided that the song I was listening to when I got through it was the reason I’d been able to pass.  So I listened to this on repeat as I tried to levitate all of this crap out of the way.  Eventually I got to the save point, but it was HARD.  That’s why I will always associate Flogging Molly with Harry Potter.

YoRWtFIW

Tell me about the first time you picked up this book?  I know many of you love the series, and I’m wondering how many of you came to it as adults?

70 Responses to “‘Oh, are you doing magic? Let’s see it, then.’”

  1. I am really looking forward to listening to the audiobooks with Ashley. She’s read the series three times now, and I’ve read it once & listened to it once.

  2. I’ve never read it, but you are completely bonkers.

    Keep it up.

  3. I was twenty-one, and training to be an English teacher. The kids were all talking about Harry Potter. My course supervisor recommended I read them. I read the first three more or less back to back, and then read them on their release dates afterwards.

    I remember all the cliches about “Ooh, they’re great stories and they’re getting children reading again!”. What impressed me most was this universe she’d created where everything seemed to work and have its own set of rules. it was very self-contained, very Tolkien in a way. But I do wish I’d noticed the numbers!

    The other thing about this was that the Dark Materials trilogy was out at around the same time, and I remember reading those and thinking “Ooh, this is Harry Potter, but so much better”. It makes me very sad that they didn’t spend the same care and love on the Hollywood adaptation of that series.

    • Oh, man. The Golden Compass movie INFURIATES me. That’s another one that makes me the most ranty that no one will watch with me.

      I feel like, as I’m reading, I can’t help but notice that JKR is a brilliant storyteller, but not really the best writer. I love her worldbuilding, and I love her characters and what she has to say, but there are bits of awkward and wonky writing throughout that (if it were really any other series) I wouldn’t be able to hold my rantiness in check.

      • I have the same thoughts about Tolkien! Wonderful characters and a fantastic story, but second-rate prose.

        I think the reason I’m utterly indifferent to the Northern Lights movie (I know why they changed it, but it is not, and NEVER WILL BE The Golden Compass as far as I’m concerned) is the fact that I’d seen it on stage in early 2004, at the South Bank in London – a six-hour adaptation of all three books (starring Patricia Hodge and Timothy Dalton, no less). You didn’t think they’d be able to pull it off. And then they did.

        • How embarrassed am I right now? Whereas with Harry Potter, I was able to procure the UK editions rather easily, I’ve only had the (wrongly titled, it seems) US editions of His Dark Materials.

          Looks like I’ll be booting up the proxy server later today (once I’ve been to bed) to catch up on what I’ve been missing.

          • No need to be embarrassed about it. I’m embarrassed, if anything, that they saw the need to once more dumb down the title for the US (cf. The Madness of King George / The Philosopher’s Stone). This apparent need to patronise you FOR NO GOOD REASON infuriates me.

            • They also did it for the sequel to The Mote in God’s Eye, which was The Moat Around Murcheson’s Eye everywhere else, but became The Gripping Hand in the US.

  4. Let’s see. I discovered it post-grad school, when everyone started talking about this amazing series I HAD to read. I was all, “kids’ books? About wizards? Meh.” But I picked up the first one, and it sucked me in. At that point, I want to say the first two (maybe even three) were out, and I devoured them. Then it was the long wait between each subsequent book. Looooong wait. I think I fell in love with the series because it was about being an outsider, and about the power of friendship – you know those things always get to me. (Still do, what, fifteen years later now, or something?)

  5. I started reading it when I was thirteen, close enough to Harry’s age. Somehow, that made the experience better.

    • I can imagine that would make everything a bit more (pardon the expression) magical. I was already far past Harry’s age when they came out, even though we’re pretty close to the same age chronologically.

  6. SJ,
    Harry Potter is an actor played by Daniel Radcliffe. These were movies made into novels. I often think the novel adaptations lack the panache of the movies. But that’s just me. Also, when I read the book adaption, I find it too difficult to imagine what a character might look like by the description, which is why I swear by the original movies only, unless it’s Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace.

    I missed the mark, didn’t I?
    Le Clown

  7. My comment disappeared into the ether. Gah. Anyway, I think I like the first book because of all the fantastic details like the sorting hat and the feasts. I was in my early teens then, I think, so obviously it worked a lot for me. My favorite of all the books in the series is Half-Blood Prince. I don’t like Snape at all (he’s an abusive dick of a teacher, really) but it was quite well-written, and it was a turning point for Draco, who is still my favorite character.

    Last Christmas my godson had the gall to tell me he hates reading, so of course I got him a hard-bound copy of the first HP book. He’s getting the rest of the series for the next six Christmases. I thought it was appropriate, too, since my godson turned eleven last year. Perfect age for the books. I’m not resting till he starts appreciating the written word.

  8. My uncle is a librarian in a middle school, and he first told me about the books (he’s introduced me to a lot of great books and video games). But I didn’t start reading them until I was spending the night in my friend’s dorm. She is a late sleeper and I’m a morning person, so in the morning while waiting for her to wake up, I found the first Harry Potter. I read most of it and enjoyed it. I bought the book later that day as well as square glasses like McGonagall’s (I needed new glasses anyway). Then I read the second, and I was disappointed. It was more of the same and just didn’t grab me in the same way. A few weeks later I was waiting for my sister in an airport and decided to buy the third book. I read most of it while waiting for her, then it was stolen in my hostel so I didn’t get a chance to finish. I didn’t come back to Harry Potter until almost a year later. I was in a depressing situation and had two deaths in my family, and the third book helped with that. After that, I transferred to a different school and got much happier. I knew changing schools was a good decision. My new roommates were also big Harry Potter fans.

  9. I started reading them not long after the first one came out, so I was in my mid-late 30s. Sucked me right in.

    And if Rowling’s trouble with dates and numbers bugs you, you might have fun reading the annotated Dracula. Stoker’s chronological abilities were pretty awful and the annotator has fun pointing that out.

    • You know, I re-read Dracula a few years ago and DID. NOT. LIKE.

      I might enjoy the annotated version, though. Thanks for the recommendation!

      • Why the not liking?

        The annotations are a lot of fun. But I love Dracula, even with all its faults. I adore Mina and wish someone would make a film version where’s she at least half as smart as she is in the book. I doubt this will ever happen.

        • If you want to see Mina as a hero, look for the graphic novel for “The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.” She’s the leader of the group. Note, do *not* look at the movie version, Sean Connery got cast as Quartermain and they completely changed the characters to favor him, mostly at Mina’s expense….picture if they cut Hermione’s good bits and gave them to, hmm, no one bad enough comes to mind. Just avoid it, and get the graphic novel. It’s full of interesting cameos, as well. :-)

  10. My aunt bought me the first three books when I was about 11. I refused to read them because I confused Harry Potter with Beatrix Potter and I therefore thought the books were about talking rabbits. Skip ahead six months, and my brother asks me to play Harry Potter with him. My response: “I don’t want to pretend to be a talking bunny”. And then he explained that I was an idiot, that the books were about witches and wizards and a magical school, and that I was an idiot. He was halfway through Chamber of Secrets, so I sped through Philosopher’s Stone in a night and stole Chamber of Secrets from him the next morning. And I’ve loved them ever since :)

    • ZOMG, that is SO CUTE! “I don’t want to pretend to be a talking bunny.”

      !!!

      Hee! I also like the way you pointed out that he made sure to tell you that you were an idiot repeatedly.

  11. I think my niece had just started reading the series. She wasn’t GUNG HO, but she liked it, and my sister was reading it too. Goblet of Fire was being released. Kids and their parents were lining up around the block for midnight releases of a damn book…and I was like…I can’t be the only one who doesn’t know what’s up. The release date was July 8, 2000, so looking back at it there’s no way my niece (who would have been 4) was reading it. SOMEONE was reading it…or maybe it’s just that it was SO POPULAR I couldn’t miss out on all the pop culture references. I don’t know.

    At the time I belonged to SFBC…The Science Fiction Book Club, and because I’d just started it, I picked the Potter trilogy as one of my freebies.

    I didn’t like the first one. I mean…it was fine, but I didn’t get the hubbub. I didn’t actually really care for the second one either. By the time I read the third one I don’t know if her writing got that much better, or I’d already developed a relationship with the characters in my mind…or both…but I liked it. I REALLY liked Goblet of Fire.

    From that point on we (my wife and I) developed a ritual. 1) Read the current book, 2) Listen to all the previous books on audio (as read by Jim Dale (my parents bought each audio book as it came out the way we bought each new book)), in preparation for 3) Watch the movie on opening day. Lather rinse repeat.

    It’s the first time my wife has gotten into a series since…well since…ever.

    • GoF was the first one I was able to get as soon as it was released.

      And then I was disappointed.

      I know we had the argument discussion this summer about the order of the series, but I still heave a great sigh when picking that one up for a re-read. Much like with WaG when I re-read the DT series.

      What is it with the fourth book?

  12. I think I first heard about Harry Potter on Rosie O’Donnell’s talk show? I grabbed a copy to read to my oldest daughter. I wish I could remember how old she was at the time..maybe 9? 10? Anyway, we fell in love. She’s going to be 21 this month and has grown up with HP and the gang. Lucky kid.

    • I was just talking to Em about how weird it is for me that there are so many people I know now that grew up with these books. I can’t remember a book series when I was a kid that EVERYONE had read.

  13. I literally discovered Harry Potter on the floor. My sister and my mom were in a mother/daughter book club with some of her friends and their mothers and had been talking about this book in the car on the way to church, trying to figure it out. Wait, actually what I think had happened is that my mom had read the book and my sister hadn’t, so she was filling her in on the plot. (This is interesting, because when I finally got my sister to read HP years later, it was what finally turned her into a reader.) I mostly ignored them, as per the usual. But then one night I happened to see a book laying on the floor of my sister’s room (rude!) and picked it up. And sat down in the middle of the hallway to read it (couldn’t even make it to my room).

    I got to the part where Harry walks into Gryffindor common room for the first time, then went to bed. I had nightmares of Harry’s fear that he was in the wrong house. That was the one and only time I ever dreamed about Harry Potter.

    I woke up the next morning, finished the book, and as they say, the rest was history. That was November 1999, so I must have been 14. Wow, what a time machine.

    • Aw, so you got to kind of grow up with them too!

      I have had weird Harry Potter dreams, too, but in mine I was at Hogwarts when the zombpocalypse came.

      • Yeah, and I really think I read them at the perfect age. I wasn’t too young or too old. Although, I would like to think that no matter what age I read them at, I would have fallen madly in love for life. HP is so a part of who I am that it’s not even a book anymore, it’s a thing that actually happened, and so criticism and stuff like that just doesn’t exist while I’m reading them. And how can you critique something that really happened?

  14. I started reading Harry Potter as an attempt to reach those children who would come into my shop, plop down in a rocking chair by the fireplace, and plant their noses into the binding of their books. They reminded me, so much, of a younger me; I wanted to know what intrigued them so. I was instantly hooked in a big way.

    I just completed a reread a few months ago, and I hadn’t read any of them since DH came out.

    • Thanks for commenting, P! I love that you read them to connect to the kids. One of the reasons I think this series has such a big part of my heart is because it was something I had that I could connect to my little brother with. With such a large gap in our ages, we didn’t always have things like this in common. His first ever midnight release (for anything) was for OotP, and I’m pretty sure he still has the number he was given in line taped in the front of his copy.

  15. There you go thinking about stuff again…

  16. I read CoS first, because my mother gave it as a Xmas present to my son, aged something like 9 – 10. She would have given the PS too, but the son said he’d already read it, and didn’t need it. He’s like that. I liked the CoS, partly, so I bought the PS myself – only, at that moment we were in Italy, and I got it in Italian. Whenever I see a starry sky, I think to myself: “Marte é molto luminosa stanotte.” ; )

    The parts I was not so very enthusiastic about in the early books were the childish orgies – very realistic and endearing, but boring… I didn’t realize the mystery-part was going to grow the way it did (PoA was an eye-opener there), so I just thought they were nice books for kids, full of action and very little descriptions – very TV-like or movie-like, so in fact Le Clown is not all off the mark.

    And so nice to hear you get cramps from GoF. I’d like to KICK Harry Potter in a big way, he’s being an incredible wuss all the book long! I tell myself it is part of the really clever storytelling by Rowling, the way to books grow with the kids – but still, that fourteen sloppiness and slow motion and lack of self-confidence, grrrrr! And I really hate that after Harry manages to construct a meaningful relation with an adult person processing really tough issues the said person turns out to be not the said person but a fake. It makes a fool of both Harry and Neville, and their issues with tortured and murdered parents.

    But PS has some of my favorite scenes still, especially Harry’s first flight and McGonagall sweeping in to make him the Gryffindor Seeker!

    • Oh, I LOVE that you still think of Ronan and Bane in Italian!

      The things you mentioned about GoF are some of my issues with the story, as well. I’ll talk about it more when I get to it, but really, it is the worst of the series for me. I even thought I’d enjoy the movie more (which I NEVER DO) because I don’t recall the book with much fondness, but they managed to make the movie WORSE than the book…and I hadn’t even thought that could be possible!

      It makes a fool of both Harry and Neville, and their issues with tortured and murdered parents.

      This. Really. It breaks my heart when I re-read, knowing that Neville really trusted in someone, and that someone turned out to’ve had a hand in taking his parents away from him. I suppose it could be said that it was all very character building and helped to pave the way for awesome Neville to emerge in the following books, but it still kills me that it happened like that.

  17. I didn’t discover HP until I was in my late 20s. Several people recommended it, but I refused to read it. Because if everyone loves it, I must hate it. I read the first one, and I was hooked. I missed out on most of the magic of midnight releases and such because I was a little too late to the game.

  18. So, I started with the movies. My son loved the first movie and I loved that it wasn’t Barney, so we watched it and cars a lot. And then the second movie too. I’m so sick of the first two movies you have no idea. I saw them a lot. But we started going to them as they came out starting with PoA. I loved this movie because it was so much darker and more adult ish than the others.
    So, one day I was at my mom’s and my brother had the fourth and fifth books, just before the fourth movie came out. I read GoF and liked it more than I thought I would and again, it was not adult. An almost main character dies, awesome. Then went on to book five. Loved it.
    Then I went back to read the first three. Ugh. What a mistake. I’ve reread them a couple of times and always wonder why. If I had read that book in 99 I would not have read another one and wondered why so many people could have read them in order.
    Now I know, they were all stuck in a car.
    Anyway, I agree. Good storyteller, mediocre writer. But boy it and she got better as it and she went on.

    • I absolutely agree that the story improved – as did Jo as a writer – as she went.

      PoA is still one of my favourites of the series, though.

  19. I first started hearing about them and having friends try to get me into them around the time the fifth book came out, but I refused to read them until the whole series was published (at which point I was 24). I’ve relaxed a bit on this rule lately, but I really do hate not being able to read a series start to finish all in one go. As it was, I was able to totally immerse myself in the world, and grow and discover the world with Harry, and just totally lose myself in it. I’m still not much of a YA person but I do love those books.

    PoA is my favorite. I say that OotP is my least favorite, and it is once the characters/writing start to mature, but I don’t much care for the first two books either. They’re just too childish for me, I think, and I mainly appreciate them as part of the whole.

  20. <3 Harry Potter! Ok short backstory: I get my love of reading from my mom and we always share books. (end backstory…see? short!). Anyway, I was about 12 when the first book came out and my mom bought and read it first. She hands it to me and says "here, read this. I think you'll really like it". We must have already known this was going to be a series because when I opened up to the first chapter and saw it titled "The Boy Who Lived" I turned to my mom and said, "Obviously he lives – the whole series is about him!" She gave me a look and said, "Just read it". And that's when my love affair with HP began.

    I got books 5, 6 & 7 at midnight openings at bookstores (and went to a few of the midnight movie premieres too) and when I was waiting to get book 6 there was a girl in line behind me who may not have even been born when the first one came out; I felt old. haha

  21. Aw, everyone has their story! So cool :D
    Well: I was in Year One at school when my mother was loaned the Stephen Fry audio for Philosopher’s Stone from a friend of hers, which my brother and l listened to on car trips and before going to sleep. Then, my teacher at the time made me read the second book with her, a chapter every few days. When the movie came out, I remember being riveted by the trailers that came on TV, especially because they were so fresh in my mind. I also remember saying the chapter names for the second movie, and my dad getting more and more unsure whether I was making it up by the time I got to Chapter 11: The Rogue Bludger (or something like that…that was also off memory :-P ). And the rest, as they say, is childhood.

  22. Hee hee, shameless plug time…I did a Potter nostalgia post here, and it may or may not include a grainy picture of 13-year-old Nerija holding her very first Potter book ;)

    Also, I totes remember that video game. My brother and I had the CD-ROM version and I remember really liking the background music. It fit the mood of each scene so nicely.

    Also, inspired by the troll section, my brother and I may or may not have invented a game called “Harry, what’s that smell?” It was basically Charades, but focused on movies, and before each turn we had to say, “Harry…what’s that smell?”

  23. I remember not taking a second look at HP until I was 17, working as a camp counselor. It was the summer when the 4th book had just come out. My campers were all obsessed with the series, and trying to retell me the stories in the way only an 8-year-old can truly botch something (“Voldemort’s the villain, right? And Padfoot really doesn’t like him, either”), but that wasn’t making me want to read it. My camp director AND my mom were both reading it, so I finally picked it up to see what the fuss was all about. Then I read the first four books straight through. Now, I’ve read them more times than I can count. :-)

  24. I first became aware of the Harry Potter phenomena from an article in a magazine. I think it was a Time left in a waiting room or maybe a restaurant with a long wait for a table. I don’t remember what made me decide to actually read the books, but I know it was a while after that. Then it became yet another book series that I started reading first and then sucked my mom into, and through her my dad. I do know that by the time Goblet of Fire was coming out, I was interested enough to want to go when another suburb announced they were turning a few shops into Diagon Alley. It wasn’t a huge thing, and by the time I got there it was rather late. My sister was visiting and my folks drove up with her for us to meet there. I hadn’t pre-ordered a book from the store there, though, so I didn’t get to join the line for midnight copies of the book.

    That suburb continued to have a Diagon Alley event, which grew with each book release; by book six there were competitors, including one of the local shopping malls, and I know my sister was with me to hop between events (and was a big advocate for staying at the mall where there was air conditioning!). One of the books there was a haunted-house-style dungeon set up with all Harry Potter theme, and I know that one I went to alone, but not sure if it was five or seven.

    Somewhere along the way, I also discovered that there were other grown-ups who were into these books, and even a whole message board of Harry Potter for Grown-Ups! I’ve always loved having a fandom, and The Invisible Man was cancelled, so diagonally filled the gap beautifully. ;-) I also ordered the ‘adult’ versions of the books from the UK or Canada, mostly because of the cool covers and the fact that they had “Harry Potter and the” in small print and the rest of the title larger (eg “Philospher’s Stone”) and I liked that look better, too. Last time I re-read the whole series I read the ‘adult’ versions and they got a few admirers.

    I’m still on the lookout for the next fandom to suck me in….

  25. I know this is several months late, but I just stumbled on to this website because of your link on Twitter to the HP drinking game. Wanted to jump in and tell my story.

    My mom is a school bus driver in New Jersey and found out about Harry Potter from kids on her bus. Not exactly sure when, but I think the first three books had already been released in the U.S., so sometime around 2000 or 2001? She became a bit of a Potterhead–seeing the movies as soon as they were in the theater, getting the books as soon as they were released, etc.

    I was already out of the house by then, living in Pittsburgh, and I was 26 years old, so I wasn’t around a lot of people who were into Harry Potter. I thought it was a little weird that my mom was (she was in her 50s). Then Harry Potter really seemed to become a phenomenon and I felt like I had missed the boat. For some reason, I decided then that I would never read a Harry Potter book or watch any of the movies.

    Fast forward to Halloween weekend 2012 (right before Hurricane Sandy hit the Jersey Shore and one month before my 37th birthday). I was visiting my parents in NJ and Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone was on HBO. Naturally, my mom wanted to watch it even though she has all eight movies on DVD. I protested at first, then gave in, then proceeded to make fun of a ton of things in the movie (particularly the child actors). She said, “if you read the books, you’d appreciate the story more.”

    Something else I discovered that fall was how to borrow e-books from my local library to read on my Nook. I was all about reading books for free. Not surprisingly, the HP books were some of the titles that didn’t have long wait lists (e.g. more than 1,000 were waiting for Gone Girl this winter when I put my name on the list). So, between December 14, 2012 and January 12, 2013, I read all seven Harry Potter books. When I would finish a book, I watched the movie and would point out to my dad all the things that were wrong about the movie. Still loved the movies, though.

    Now, I own all the e-books and am participating in Once Upon a Chapter’s group-read-along. I went to the Harry Potter Exhibition in NYC wearing a Hufflepuff scarf. I own all the deluxe editions of the eight movies and have seen each of them at least four times (plus all the extra content). And finally, I daydream about owning a house with a guest room decorated to look like a Hogwarts dormitory.

    When I read PS/SS, I originally gave it 4 stars on Goodreads. By the time I finished CoS, I was totally enthralled with the magical HP world and the characters in it. So, the remaining six books got 5 stars each. Then, I went back and changed PS/SS to 5 stars. Now that I’m re-reading all seven books (we’re only six chapters in right now), I suppose I’ll be more critical. I wonder how my opinions will change.

    • Oh, I love this story! I’ve given in to my inner critic upon re-reading this time (but I really hope people don’t think it means I don’t still love the books).

      I have a Ravenclaw hat and scarf, I’ll probably post pictures when I talk about Luna.

      Oh, and I made myself a Weird Sisters shirt that I wore to the DH release party that everyone wanted.

      • Thanks! Glad I shared my story. I’m going to bookmark this blog and read your reviews. They’re hilarious!

        The online community you mentioned is intriguing to me. Sad it doesn’t exist anymore. I would love to have a discussion about horcruxes. How do they work? When Voldemort’s spell rebounded in the Potter’s house and *almost* killed Voldemort, did he have to be near to one of his horcruxes to stay alive? Once you “use” one of your horcruxes to come back to life, is that object no longer a horcrux?

        My favorite book in the series is GoF because there was so much going on. For that same reason, I thought the movie was crap because they had to eliminate so much of the story. My second favorite of the series is HBP because I love the flashbacks that tell Tom Riddle’s history.

        • Oh, we’re all still sad that the site imploded, but we’ve mostly found each other on Facebook so conversations still happen. I wish it was still around so I could send people over!

          Good questions about the horcruxes! I’ll have to remember them when we get to that point and throw it out there.

          HBP is my favourite of the series, and it’s probably because of all the Riddle backstory.

          (and you said I’m hilarious! Day=Made)

Trackbacks

Comments make us happy. Leave lots of comments. Just don't be a snapebag or you'll face the wrath of dodisharkicorn and your comment will be deleted. Or we'll make fun of you. Or both. Probably both.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,026 other followers

%d bloggers like this: