Print vs Digital: One Book Snob’s Opinion

by sj
Pretty sure I'm wishing I had a book.

Pretty sure I’m wishing I had a book.

My dad talks all the time about how I was reading before my 4th birthday, and that I would drive him crazy with what we now call Random Acts of Roadside Literacy.  I read everything.  EVERYTHING.  Signs, billboards, labels, tags on pillows, anything and everything that had letters printed on it.

When I went to school, I’d get in trouble for trying to stay inside to read during recess.  My school librarian was my best friend and when I got in trouble with my dad, he took my books away.  Any other punishment had no effect on me, so he knew I’d pay attention if I had a few days without my “friends.”

Through junior high and high school, I spent all of my vacations, time on the bus before and after school, walking through the hallways between classes…all of my free time was spent reading and re-reading my favourite books, spending my entire allowance at used book stores to feed my habit.

The library was great, but when I lived in Montana, our library was only open a few days a week (and I volunteered there so that I had another excuse to spend all of my time with my nose in a book) and the closest DECENT library was over an hour away in another state.

For our first few years together, my husband knew that birthdays, Christmas and Just Because I Love You presents should be books.  I didn’t want jewelry, flowers or chocolates, I wanted books.

Then I developed arthritis in my hands, and the eczema that had been mostly contained on my limbs spread to the backs of my hands and my fingers.

Suddenly, reading was no longer the escape it had been my entire life.  Reading was uncomfortable and painful.  It was difficult to hold a book open, I’d have to break the spine (!) to prop it open in front of me, and hope that I didn’t ruin the pages with my cracked fingers.

I kind of…I didn’t give up on reading, but I enjoyed it a lot less – and therefore didn’t read as much as I always had – for several years.

Then my dad got me an eReader as a gift.  I kind of shrugged it off and in public was very grateful, but in my head made snobby comments about how nothing could replace real books.  I read a book on it, then let the battery fully discharge  and didn’t touch it for about six months.

Until my hands got particularly bad and I knew there was just no way I could force myself to even pick up a book, let alone turn the pages.

sj_nookSo I charged it, and checked out a bunch of books from my local library (without even leaving my house!).  No longer did I have to worry about breaking the spine, or making my hands worse with paper cuts, all I needed was a free finger to tap and turn the page!

I still have that eReader (it’s hopelessly dated now, without wifi or anything else fancy – really, it’s just for reading) but my dad got me a new one THIS Christmas, so I passed that one on to my 13 year old.  He loves it as much as I did, and it makes me smile to walk into his room and see him curled up reading.  He announces when he finishes something, then starts his next book without even having to get up.  13 year old me is VERY jealous.

In answer to this week’s Weekly Writing Challenge, which asks if we prefer eBooks or Paperbacks, I have to say – I used to be a dead tree book snob, but even if I were to miraculously no longer have issues with my hands, I’d stick with digital.  I realized that I love reading more than I love the books themselves, it’s the words that have the power for me, not the pages.

About these ads

50 Comments to “Print vs Digital: One Book Snob’s Opinion”

  1. I love my books too much to switch over completely. I doubt I would have an e-reader at all if it weren’t for you. I do like my e-reader very much, but I collect children’s books. The lovely illustrations are not the same on a device.

  2. I have muscular problems (whole damn arm) and have come to love my e-reader. I still own shelves of old books and adore them, but most of my new fiction purchases are digital now.

    • I am kind of in the process of getting rid of a lot of the books I have that don’t have sentimental value. There are some that have strong memories attached, and I’ll keep those forever, but others were inexpensive paperbacks that I won’t miss.

      • When I recently got a *shipping notice* from Amazon that a book I’d pre-ordered like a year ago was finally on the way, and I had a small tantrum because I thought I’d ordered it for the Kindle and it was too late to fix now, I knew I’d crossed the Rubicon.

        The tendons in my elbows are degenerated to an appalling degree and my body’s inept attempt at healing them has left me with bone spurs in my elbows, too (like little razor blades making microtears in my tissues every time I move!), so I may never be able to read physical books or comics again, and I even have to depend on a case for my Kindle that makes it a free-standing thing. I can manage reaching out and hitting a button every few seconds. I can manage that.

        I would have gone right out of my mind and ended it all if this technology had not come along when it had. And, like SJ, I am in the process of purging a lot of less-treasured physical books from my home. My beloved first edition hardcovers of Umberto Eco and Alastair Reynolds and Neal Stephenson and Tim Powers, and my Library of America editions of Lovecraft and Dick and Wharton and James, those stay with me until I die, but mass market paperbacks that aren’t vintage treasures from the 60s? Not so much.

  3. Hehe, this childhood sounds soooo familiar =) And I too have abandoned paper books in favour of my lovely Sony Reader, but for another reason: 2 years ago I moved to another country, and it’s not that easy to purchase books in another language here. Moreover, I’ve moved ~6 times while here, and all my library was there in my bag, only 300gr or so =) Love technology!

  4. “it’s the words that have the power for me, not the pages.”

    Well put.

    I’m still not firmly in the ereader camp, but I’m getting there slowly. (It’s much easier to hold up an ereader when I’m lying in bed then to have to turn the page and adjust my position because now I need to read the floppy side of the book or whatever. I’m describing this badly.)

  5. I read all my books on my phone, and can’t remember when I last read a paper book. (Or actually I do: it was Amy’s Out of True.)

    With two small children, I only get a few minutes of reading time here and there so having the books instantly available on my phone is the only real way to get to read anything at all. But to be fair, I read everything on my phone even before we had children. Just like with my music collection, having everything constantly available and with me wherever I go has changed the way I look at reading and listening to music forever.

    • I’ve read a few paper books in the last year (one was Amy’s, the others were ARCs), but I kept tapping for definitions or to highlight. Plus, it really is a lot more difficult to carve out two minutes of reading time with a dead tree book.

  6. In what part of Montana did you live?

    • A tiny town of less than 300 in the NW. 12 miles from the Idaho border, south of BC. The closest Montana city was Missoula, which was a 3 hour drive.

  7. Love it – especially after our chat about e-readers the other day. :) Since Christmas I’ve already read 7 books because of having that Kindle around with me all the time. Life is busy but getting to fill in those spaces of waiting with reading time is awesome! Hearing why you went to the e-reader makes perfect sense and I’m so glad it’s worked for you!

  8. Yeah, I prefer using my Kindle than faffing about with paper books. It’s just far more convenient.

    And the school librarian took your books away when your dad was cross at you? Bit harsh, like.

  9. I still read paper books, mostly, but I really want to get an e-reader soon. I’ve started checking one out of the library pretty regularly and am always so sad when I have to return. No renewing e-readers. *pout*

  10. I realized that I love reading more than I love the books themselves, it’s the words that have the power for me, not the pages.

    This is a fantastic statement, and it’s very true. I’m glad that the e-reader has worked out well for you. :)

  11. I love my kindle! I love one handed reading. I like to read in bed. I LOVE not having every square inch of my house taken up with bookshelves. Love it so much! (But I agree, the whole illustration thing sucks. And footnotes, since they always get lumped at the end of a chapter. But you can’t have EVERYTHING can you?)

    • Oh, the FOOTNOTES! Yes, those are a thorn in my side. The cool thing about my new Nook, though is that I can easily click on the footnote, then go directly back to the last page I was reading, just like in a dead tree book!

  12. I was always a book snob too, preferring to stick with the “real” thing rather than investing in an e-reader. But after hearing some wonderful things about them, I finally broke down and bought a Nook a few weeks ago. It has the glow light so I can read in the dark without straining my eyes, and you’re right, being able to have another book at your fingertips in a matter of seconds is a beautiful thing.

  13. I will blog about this someday when I have time, but I was VIOLENTLY anti-e-reader up until recently. Then, Kindle. And now…oh, I love the Kindle. Man, do I love the Kindle. Do I still love tree-books? Yep. But oh, that Kindle.

    Two things: a., we are sisters separated at birth with the descriptions of our reading in childhood, and b., you look so much like your kiddos in that photo of you. Those wee-sj eyes are FILLED with mischief, too. I love it so so much.

    • The oldest looks almost exactly like me. Middlest son looks like his daddy, and youngest two look like each other…which is a perfect combination of the two of us.

  14. SJ, I LOVE your blog! Your writing is fluid and lovely and you have this way of tapping straight into that place in my soul that I sometimes forget is there. Books have always been my friends, too and our house is bursting with books. Even though we all have eReaders, we all still love “book” books. My daughter is the same. Her reasoning? She likes the look, the feel, the smell and the ability to foist the stories on her friends when she’s done reading. She’s said it herself: no one wants to be a lone fan girl. She’s an unapologetic ‘book pusher’ and her friends just accept this as fact.

    • Aw, Val! This comment totally made my day. Thank you. You know I already think your daughter is pretty awesome, but hearing that about her makes me like her even more.

  15. Same same. I have early onset Macular Degeneration and HAD stopped reading for pleasure, which reallllly depressed me. I tried audio books, but they are a whole different kettle of fish. Then a lovely friend on Twitter was selling a Nook Color still under warranty because it was too heavy for her. I bought it and have never looked back. I LOVE my ereader and can read novels again, even if I have to make the print silly-big.
    I get tired of people going on and on about “real” books and how superior they are. I can take the 3 – 5 books I am usually reading with me wherever I go, I don’t have to store them and I can get free books from Project Gutenberg. The backlighting lets me read in any situation, pretty much and I can prop the Nook up and read while I knit. So there!

    • Ohhh, one of my husband’s friends started suffering from macular degeneration as a teen. By the time he was 20, he was not really able to read on his own anymore.

      I may be incredibly nearsighted, but I’m grateful every day that I CAN still read. <3

    • My mother has Stargardt’s Disease (a form of early-onset Macular Degeneration). Watching her actually READ a book now is so wonderful.

  16. Just re-read that. How superior paper books are, I meant, not the people who read them. Just to clarify.

  17. Ereaders changed my mother’s reading life, too. Three cheers for ereaders!

  18. You know, I’m perversely glad to know that I’m not the only kid whose most horrifying punishment was to have their books taken away.

    • YOU TOO?! Everyone usually looks at me like I’m crazy when I tell them that!

      • I don’t remember what I did to warrant it, but my mum actually took all my books from my room once and put them in drawers in the closet in the spare room. She didn’t lock anything up, but she DID put a piece of tissue paper at the top hinge to see if I’d been in that closet.

        …I used to read a lot of mystery novels, and I noticed the paper flutter down when I broke in to get my books. Managed to illicitly smuggle novels out for a week before she caught me.

  19. I haven’t made the move to e-reading yet. Mostly because I’m too cheap. ;) I’ll get there though, probably sooner rather than later. I’m having wrist issues, elbow issues…reading injuries? I don’t know but whatever can make reading more pleasant is cool with me.

    Your childhood sounds very familiar to me. Very.

  20. Having a baby in one hand has given me new appreciation for an iPad in the other.

    Also, I’m reading Brothers Karamozov, and the “real” version is about 15 pounds.

  21. I fully admit I thought all the e-reading perks and awards and badges and social media connections were a bit extraneous, if not silly, before I got one. Now that I have a Kobo, I’ve come to love have a library of books with me everywhere I go, making notes in them ruining the “pages,” and earning all the pretty badges which are still silly but that, like digital watches to my primitive brain, still seem like a Pretty Neat Idea. I also love reading in bed in the dark — woke up at the godawful hour of f4:30 on Christmas Day and was afraid of waking the fam up, so I stayed where I was and FINISHED A BOOK IN PEACE and holy crap was that awesome. In the dark!

  22. Did I just comment by logging in a different way? Gah, I am so incompetent. Or else I exist in too many forms online.

Comments make us happy. Leave lots of comments. Just don't be a snapebag or you'll face the wrath of dodisharkicorn and your comment will be deleted. Or we'll make fun of you. Or both. Probably both.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,027 other followers

%d bloggers like this: