“Together they took turns kicking the stranger.”

by sj

problem childThe Problem Child is the third Sisters Grimm book in a series of [runs off to check]…nine. Really? Nine? Holy crap, I should have checked into this before I got The Boy all into them.

Okay, so I talked a little bit here about why I’m reading these, and the ARDUOUS PACE my 13y/o is setting for me.  He doesn’t cut me any slack when it comes to these, because he hasn’t yet picked up his mother’s bad habit of having eleventy billion books going at once.

So what did I do all day today?  I finished this book, of course, so that I can be ahead of him and have a little breathing room when it comes to the schedule he’s set for us.

I guess all of that is really neither here nor there, though.  For those of you that are too lazy to click that link up there, The Sisters Grimm is a series of books by Michael Buckley, and it bears a striking resemblance to the television series Once Upon a Time.  There’s a town (in the books it’s in New York, in the series, it’s in Maine) full of all the faerie tale creatures/people we know from the works of Grimm, Lang, Andersen, Baum, etc.

In the first book, we met Sabrina and Daphne Grimm, sisters whose parents disappeared one stormy night, and since then they’ve been bouncing around through the system, moving from orphanage to orphanage, foster home to foster home…until their social worker finds a grandmother they didn’t even know they had.

Sabrina (11) has a difficult time accepting the fact that Relda Grimm is really their grandmother, her father hasn’t ever mentioned his parents, after all – she has an even harder time accepting the notion that Ferryport Landing is a “safe haven” for faerie tale creatures, and that the Grimms are basically in charge of keeping them out of the way of humanity.

Things happen, and the girls learn that their parents aren’t really dead (of course).  The long arc is Sabrina and Daphne trying to bring them home.  The books follow the monster of the week format, in the first it’s Jack (he of the beanstalks), in the second it’s Rumplestiltskin…but in the third it’s Little Red Riding Hood.

I was rather meh about this series up until this third book.  They were cute, and I appreciated how many of the details Buckley got right, but I was also very aware that I was reading a series for children.

The Problem Child, though – it goes beyond “cute” and starts to deal with topics like mental illness and addiction.  Heady stuff for a younger crowd.  But it’s handled deftly and without a lot of finger pointing and shaming.  I really liked that we were made to understand exactly WHY our villain went ’round the bend, and I think it was done in such a way that even VERY YOUNG readers will understand and sympathize.  Addiction is handled in a similar manner (in this instance, it’s an addiction to magic) and consequences are very clearly shown, as is how it can be made to seem alluring.

No, of course it won’t replace talking to your kids about such things, but if you’ve already had a discussion on the topic, this can reinforce it – similarly, it might be a good way to bring the subject UP if you haven’t already.

I have to admit, after finishing The Unusual Suspects last week, I wasn’t in much of a hurry to continue the series (I am still hoping to get the kid into my books of faerie tales, but I think it’ll have to wait for now) – but I’m very much looking forward to picking up Once Upon a Crime later this week.

(Also, I LOVED what happened with The Little Mermaid in this book.  That’s all I’m sayin’.)

YoRWtFIW

17 Comments to ““Together they took turns kicking the stranger.””

  1. Huh. I just tried to leave a comment and it ate it.

    Let’s try this again!

    I love the idea of these books, and it sounds like I’ll really like this one in particular. I ADORE “books for younger readers” that tackle complex issues in complex ways and don’t dumb things down. Kids are smart; treat them like it.

    • Yeah, I was really impressed with how it was handled. At one point, we see a list of faerie tale characters that were being treated for mental health issues, and all of them made a lot of sense.

      I particularly liked the way addiction was handled. Daphne (she’s 7) has a hard time getting the word right, but she’s able to see the impact it has made on her family, it’s not talking down to the kids at all.

      There’s a tiny bit of…I hesitate to call it fat-shaming, because it isn’t really, and it made sense within the context of the story. I’d really like someone else to read this one so I have someone to discuss that with. Basically, one of the princesses was dumped and eats to compensate.

  2. They sound a little like a combination of “OUaT,” the “Fables” series of comics, and the show “Grimm,” all of which I really enjoy. And I love that your son is enjoying them so much!

  3. I got mostly through the first book in this series and set it aside for something else. I thought it started out so great and then it just kind of flopped. Sounds so much better the way you tell it though. Of course, I would have liked them a lot better if I had been reading them with one of my children.

    • The first book wasn’t all that special. I only picked up the second after my son started reading them. They definitely got better, starting with the second book.

  4. I love the “twist on fairy tale” movement in books and TV, although I might be getting a little overwhelmed with the movies. Every time I see a new take on them, I think, “I wish I had thought of that!”

  5. Argh, comment got eaten by the Internets! :( Apologies if this ends up as a double-post.

    . . . .

    Nerija’s comment, Take 2:

    . . . .

    Sigh. *adds Sisters Grimm to TBR(ead) list that is now crossing the Panama Canal*

    Did I already mention this awesome faerie-tale-twisting webcomic? (in an unrelated note, have I also mentioned my occasionally Dori-the-fish-like memory? ^_^;; ) It’s on the darker side — I’m not sure if it’s appropriate for the 13-year-old, although what violence there is didn’t feel gratuitous or overdone to me — especially with Red and the old woman in the woods.

    Only thing is, the author/artist can be verrrry slow to update. She’s been posting pages more frequently these past few months, but before that there’d been a year or so in between updates. Anyhoo, at least there’s lots of archived material.

  6. This sounds like a fun series! I’ve actually been delving back into some of my favorite books from childhood so this could fit right in with all of that. Will have to check them out!

  7. I do not like it when you remind me that I haven’t read everything I might ever have liked. Also, I now have a full, single version of the first part of my novel? Are you still up for browsing it? It will be too late to make any changes, I thinks, unless you have some free time right now. I really want your opinion, even if it costs me the one or two dollars I would have tried to shake you down for.

  8. I read the first book for my children’s literature course in college several years ago. I liked it, but haven’t had the opportunity to pick the rest up. I had kind of forgotten about them, but I bet my younger son would like them. He’s quite an avid reader. :)

Comments make us happy. Leave lots of comments. Just don't be a snapebag or you'll face the wrath of dodisharkicorn and your comment will be deleted. Or we'll make fun of you. Or both. Probably both.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,028 other followers

%d bloggers like this: